Author: Hooper, Jason A.
Title: Heinrich Schenkerâ€™s Early Approach to Form, 1895â€“1921: Implications for His Late Work and Its Reception
Institution: CUNY Graduate Center
Begun: January 2009
Completed: February 2017
This dissertation constructs Heinrich Schenkerâ€™s early approach to form and traces its development as his organic theory of transformational voice leading emerged in the early 1920s. Schenkerâ€™s late approach to form is then briefly reconsidered from this newfound perspective.
Chapter 1 defines the nineteenth-century Formenlehre tradition established by A.Â B. Marx and passed down to Anton Bruckner through his studies in model composition, leading to Schenker himself. Chapter 2 presents Schenkerâ€™s early approach to form in a generative fashion, demonstrating how a single motive can grow into a large thematic group unified by a single key area or an economy of Stufen. Chapter 3 introduces the schemas that Schenker developed in the 1910s to analyze full-movement forms, from one-part form to six-part cyclic form. Chapter 4 reappraises Schenkerâ€™s later work, including the inherent conflict between the continuity of counterpoint (as in J.Â S. Bachâ€™s fugues) and the discontinuity of musical form (as in Beethovenâ€™s sonatas). The Formenlehre expressed in Der freie Satz (1935) is viewed as an attempt to unify these two â€œmusical culturesâ€ through a single cause (Halm 1913): the backgroundâ€™s dynamic transformation into the foreground.
Yet this union of voice leading and form is not always convincing. The schematic forms described in the last chapter of Der freie Satz (1935) are identical to those encountered in Schenkerâ€™s work twenty years earlier. Schenker claims to derive these forms from the background as a matter of generative theoryâ€”but as a matter of history, they predate his apprehension of the background altogether. Given this insight, I contend that the relationship between form and content is reciprocal: form is best understood not only as a surface manifestation of tonal forces emanating from the background but also as a co-determining force that shapes deeper levels of voice-leading structure (C.Â Smith 1996). The latter force is manifest through interruption: Schenkerâ€™s last theoretical concept, which enabled him to integrate organic voice leading with a more traditional Formenlehre (Rothstein 2001; Samarotto 2005). This dissertation therefore rejects the monism permeating Schenkerâ€™s late work and calls for a return to his original conception of Synthese, in which independent musical parameters are integrated rather than fully subsumed by the controlling influence of the Ursatz (Korsyn 1988; Cohn 1992a, 1992b; Lubben 1993; Cook 2007; Brody 2015).
Keywords: Heinrich Schenker, Formenlehre, sonata form, organicism, causality, synthesis
Chapter 1: Against the Formenlehre Tradition
Chapter 2: A Generative Approach to Form
Chapter 3: A Conformational Approach to Form
Chapter 4: Toward an Organic Approach to Form
Appendix 1: The Path to Resemblance
Appendix 2: On the Nature of Artistic Laws in General
Appendix 3: On Musical Causality
Appendix 4: A Compendium of Schenkerâ€™s Forms
Department of Music & Dance
University of Massachusetts Amherst
273 Fine Arts Center East
151 Presidents Dr., Ofc. 1
Amherst, MA 01003-9330